Talk:Shadow Galactica

From WikiMoon
Jump to: navigation, search

How would you guys classify the nine soldiers of the solar system when they come under the control of Galaxia? They aren't like Lethe, etc. because they didn't do it by choice, but they aren't like the Animamates because they didn't kill a senshi for the power. The should probably be listed on this page if Sailor Uranus and Neptune are listed for their part in the manga.--Sakky 18:06, 3 October 2006 (MST)

Hmm. Of the choices, they would fit best under "True Sailor Senshi", though you might want to note that some of the Senshi joined voluntarily and some involuntarily. Kerochan no Miko 20:24, 3 October 2006 (MST)
Okay I added it, so let me know if you think that makes sense. Also, on the pages for the solar senshi, there isn't any mention of their attacks under Shadow Galactica. I realize that it's only a few pages in the manga, but if we note it on this page and people follow the links to the soldier, there should be information about that time and their powers in the manga sections, right?--Sakky 08:07, 4 October 2006 (MST)
Perhaps we should move Tuxedo Mask to Miscellaneous? By Naoko's definition he is not a Sailor Senshi... though he is a Sailor Crystal carrier. --GracieLizzie 12:52, 4 October 2006 (MST)
That seems reasonable to me. Since MC Fly is listed under Miscellaneous, I feel like Tuxedo Mask should join him there - they're direct parallels. Also, is it necessary to have a "Star Garderners" section? Presumably those guys are true Sailor Senshi, and we don't give Lethe and Mnemosyne a seperate section according to their function. It's awkward.--Dallbun 18:18, 31 March 2007 (MST)

The list of Shadow Galactica members says "Please note that this list combines the anime, manga, and Sera Myu members, and only lists those who joined Shadow Galactica willingly (i.e. the sailor soldiers in manga Act 51 - Stars 9 and the Inner Senshi in the Sera Myu musicals do not count)." At the moment, this is distinctly untrue. Should we remove the unwilling people again, or should we remove that line?--Dallbun 18:18, 31 March 2007 (MST)

I added Shadow Galactica members from the musicals to the list. For the record, the Amazon Trio are revived to serve in Shin Densetsu Kourin; Sailor Buttress is Galaxia's right-hand woman in Sailor Stars; Chaos is Galaxia's flunky in Eien Densetsu; and Endymion is revived to please Beryl in Eien Densetsu as well.--Dallbun 18:18, 31 March 2007 (MST)

銀河の影" (lit. "Galactic Shadow)
I'm a little iffy on calling that "galactic shadow" because, IMHO, the phrasing is a little bit...awkward-sounding. "Shadow of a/the galaxy" is longer but less weird-sounding in my mind, considering that "galactic" isn't exactly a common adjective (and can also refer to milk production, so, weird connotations). And couldn't 銀河 be specifically referring to the Milky Way as well, or am I mistaken? Kerochan no Miko 07:57, 21 December 2008 (MST)

Actually I also felt a lil awkward, but since it can't be said to be outrightly wrong either, I didn't edit that part. "Shadow of the Galaxy" does sound better. And yeah, "銀河" (lit. "Silver River") can refer to our Milky Way galaxy, depending on the context of its use. --210 06:26, 22 December 2008 (MST)

_________________ So...

If this article:

"only lists those who joined Shadow Galactica willingly (i.e. the Senshi in manga Act 51 and the Inner Senshi in the musicals do not count)."

then why does this list include them then? I think it should be deleted... and just include everyone who was part of the group at some point, regardless of will. Also its never been cleared up. Tuxedo Kamen, I think should be in Miscellaneous. he takes the PLACE of Sailor Earth, that is not the same as being Sailor Earth. He doesn't have a collar and isn't female, after all the golden rule "only girls can be Sailor Senshi".... He isn't some anime alteration either so the Starlights are irrelevant here. And Finally... should Mirror Paedri be included as monsters-of-the-day? Because Nehellenia has also been included here... 00:15, 7 January 2011 (MST)

It lists everyone who voluntarily joined Shadow Galactica in at least one version of the series, then notes if they joined involuntarily in another one. I don't know what the tangent about Sailor Earth has to do with anything, however. Kerochan no Miko 02:39, 8 January 2011 (MST)
But you've listed some that are involuntarily only. So there's no point in saying it listed only those who joined willingly. There seems to be no point in that addition,. I'm saying Tuxedo Kamen should be moved from True Sailor Senshi to Miscellaneous. And... should Mirror Paedri be added to monsters-of-the-day? Minakoaino 16:12, 8 January 2011 (MST)

As previously discussed, the list of members should only include those who voluntarily joined Shadow Galactica in at least one version of canon -- if they joined voluntarily in one but involuntarily in another (such as Uranus and Neptune) they're still on the list with a clarifying note. I removed Tuxedo Mask because I don't think he voluntarily joined in any continuity, and King Endymion because the musical "mudpuppet" version wasn't actually Endymion. Kerochan no Miko 11:23, 19 March 2011 (MST)

Okay, seriously, is it that hard to actually discuss the whole "mudpuppet" thing here instead of just edit-warring it? 9_9 Kerochan no Miko 00:22, 26 March 2011 (MST)
They can walk, talk, think for themselves and participate in the runnings of the Shadow Galactica. It no longer says that they are Tuxedo Kamen and King Endymion which was the initial problem I believe. They are members even if they aren't human, taking the guise of two characters Cartwheelingfiesta 00:31, 26 March 2011 (MST)
Which is why I left it this time. My point, however, is that that point should have been discussed here as I requested when I originally removed those entries instead of having them repeatedly re-added without comment. Kerochan no Miko 00:36, 26 March 2011 (MST)
Oh mys. I'm sorry =\ They were correcting the problem from before which is why I didn't think I needed to comment. I'm sorry I wasn't thinking Cartwheelingfiesta 00:47, 26 March 2011 (MST)

Mirror Paredri

I think this issue should be settle once and for all. Are Mirror Paredri affiliated to the Shadow Galactica and therefore should be included in the monsters of the day category yes or no? I think that seeing as they were helping Nehellenia who was helping Galaxia that they are. Since Nehellenia is affiliated with Shadow Galactica, I think they should be too. Any oppositions? -- Sailor Simon 20:50, 9 May 2011 (EST)

Nehellenia may have been working with Galaxia's help, but she didn't seem to realize it and wasn't deliberately one of her minions. It could really be seen either way, since they were created at Galaxia's urging, but since they followed only Nehellenia's command I would lean toward no, personally. Kerochan no Miko 19:01, 9 May 2011 (MST)